Gothic Art

Gothic Architecture: Pointed Arches, Vaults and Buttresses

Gothic architecture, from about 1140, used pointed arches, rib vaults and flying buttresses to build tall cathedrals full of light.

Paris, Notre-Dame, flying buttresses of the apse, late 12th-14th century
Paris, Notre-Dame, flying buttresses of the apse, late 12th-14th century. Limestone. Paris. Stone arms that reach over the aisles to hold up the high walls.Photo: Eutouring, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The short answer

Gothic architecture is the way Europeans built churches from about 1140 to 1500. It rests on three inventions working together: the pointed arch, the ribbed vault and the flying buttress. Combined, they moved the weight of the roof onto a few points, so walls could become thinner, higher and almost entirely glass.

The problem it solved

Romanesque churches had round arches and stone vaults, which push outwards along the whole length of the walls. To resist that push, walls had to be thick and windows small, as the guide to Romanesque art explains. Builders in the Île-de-France, the region around Paris, wanted the opposite: tall churches full of light. In the 1140s, at Saint-Denis, they began to put together the solutions that defined the new style, the subject of the hub on Gothic art.

The pointed arch: more height, less push

A round arch has one fixed shape: its height is always half its width. A pointed arch, made of two curves meeting at a point, can be as tall or as narrow as the builder needs, so arches of different widths can reach the same height. It also directs more of the weight downwards and less sideways, which means less outward thrust on the walls. It is the difference between a wide, low bridge and a tall, narrow one: the steeper the curve, the more it presses down rather than out.

Geometric diagram of pointed arches of different spans rising to the same height over a square bay and an oblong one, wi
Geometric diagram of pointed arches of different spans rising to the same height over a square bay and an oblong one, with the diagonal lines of the ribs. Drawing, from Charles Herbert Moore’s study of Gothic architecture. With pointed arches the ribs can reach the same height over spans of different widths.Photo: Charles Herbert Moore, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Pointed arches were not new. They had been used in Islamic architecture for centuries and appear in some Romanesque churches. What was new was using them systematically, together with the other two inventions.

The rib vault: a skeleton of stone

A rib vault is a stone ceiling divided by projecting ribs that cross diagonally, like the frame of an umbrella. The ribs were built first, on wooden centring, and the thin panels between them were filled in afterwards. The ribs gather the weight of the vault and bring it down to the corners of each bay, onto the piers, instead of spreading it along the wall. Early rib vaults had already appeared at Durham, in England, in the 1090s; Gothic builders made them lighter and higher.

Rib vault seen from below, Maria Saal Cathedral, Carinthia, Austria, 15th century
Rib vault seen from below, Maria Saal Cathedral, Carinthia, Austria, 15th century. Stone. Follow the ribs from the keystone at the centre down to the columns.Photo: Qwertzu111111, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The flying buttress: support from outside

Even with pointed arches and rib vaults, the high vaults of a cathedral still push outwards at the top of the walls. The answer was the flying buttress: an arch of stone that leaps over the side aisle from an outer pier to the upper wall, catching the thrust where it acts. Among the first were those added to Notre-Dame in Paris around 1180. From the outside, a Gothic cathedral looks like a building surrounded by its own scaffolding, and in a sense it is.

Section of a Gothic cathedral: nave, aisles, buttresses and flying buttresses carrying the thrust of the high vault
Section of a Gothic cathedral: nave, aisles, buttresses and flying buttresses carrying the thrust of the high vault. Drawing. The weight travels through the flyers to the outer piers and down to the ground.Photo: Lusitana (original:User:TTaylor, translated by User:HLHJ), CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

With the weight carried by piers and buttresses, the walls between them no longer held the building up. They could be opened into huge windows, the glass described in the guide to stained glass.

Inside: arcade, triforium, clerestory

A typical High Gothic nave rises in three levels. At the bottom is the arcade, the row of arches that opens onto the aisles. Above it runs the triforium, a narrow passage or band of small arches. At the top is the clerestory, a row of tall windows that lights the nave. The proportions of these levels changed from cathedral to cathedral, and the trend was always the same: taller windows, thinner supports.

Diagram of a Gothic nave wall with the clerestory, the upper band of windows, highlighted
Diagram of a Gothic nave wall with the clerestory, the upper band of windows, highlighted. Drawing. Each level gets lighter as it goes up.Photo: Xvdces, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The same diagram with the arcade highlighted at the bottom
The same diagram with the arcade highlighted at the bottom. Drawing. The arches of the arcade open the nave to the aisles.Photo: Xvdces, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The same diagram with the vault highlighted at the top
The same diagram with the vault highlighted at the top. Drawing. The ribs gather the weight of the roof and pass it down to the piers.Photo: Xvdces, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The race for height reached its limit at Beauvais, where the choir vault rose to about 48 metres, the highest of any Gothic cathedral. In 1284 part of it collapsed; it was rebuilt with extra supports, and the nave was never built. The cathedrals of Chartres, Reims and Amiens show the system at its most balanced.

Beauvais Cathedral, choir, vault about 48 m high, partly rebuilt after 1284
Beauvais Cathedral, choir, vault about 48 m high, partly rebuilt after 1284. Stone and glass. Beauvais, France. The tallest Gothic choir ever built, and the one that fell.Photo: Diliff, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

English Gothic: long, low and decorated

In England the style took its own path. Salisbury Cathedral, built mostly between 1220 and 1258, is long and horizontal, with a spire of about 123 metres, added in the fourteenth century and still the tallest in Britain. Later English Gothic, called Perpendicular, covered walls with straight vertical panelling and invented the fan vault, where ribs spread like the ribs of a fan, as in the cloister of Gloucester and the ceiling of King’s College Chapel in Cambridge (1508-1515).

Salisbury Cathedral, 1220-1258, spire 14th century
Salisbury Cathedral, 1220-1258, spire 14th century. Stone. Salisbury, England. A long, low cathedral under the tallest spire in Britain.Photo: Diego Delso, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Cambridge, King's College Chapel, fan vault, 1508-1515
Cambridge, King’s College Chapel, fan vault, 1508-1515. Stone. Cambridge. Ribs opening like fans across the whole ceiling.Photo: Txllxt TxllxT, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Across Europe, and a long afterlife

Gothic spread to every corner of Latin Europe. Cologne Cathedral, begun in 1248 on the French model, was left unfinished for centuries and completed only in 1880, following the medieval drawings. In Italy, builders preferred wide spaces and less height, with the great exception of the Duomo of Milan, begun in 1386, with its forest of pinnacles. In the nineteenth century the Gothic Revival brought the style back for churches, parliaments and universities, from London to New York.

Cologne Cathedral, begun 1248, completed 1880
Cologne Cathedral, begun 1248, completed 1880. Stone. Cologne, Germany. A medieval design finished six centuries later.Photo: Thomas Wolf, http://www.foto-tw.de, CC BY-SA 3.0 de, via Wikimedia Commons
Milan Cathedral, the roof terraces and pinnacles, begun 1386
Milan Cathedral, the roof terraces and pinnacles, begun 1386. Marble. Milan. You can walk among the pinnacles on the roof.Photo: Pilgab, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

When the Renaissance came, Italian architects rejected all this for the round arches and proportions of ancient Rome, described in the guide to Renaissance architecture. But the three Gothic inventions had already done what they were meant to do: they turned the stone church into a frame for light.

Where to see it

Paris and its region are the best place to start, with Notre-Dame, the Sainte-Chapelle and Saint-Denis, then the cathedrals of Chartres, Amiens and Reims, each an easy day trip. In England, Salisbury, Wells and King’s College Chapel; in Germany, Cologne; in Italy, Milan.

Sources

  • The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, “Gothic Architecture”.
  • R. Mark, Experiments in Gothic Structure (Cambridge, Mass., 1982).
  • C. Wilson, The Gothic Cathedral (London, 1990).
  • J. Bony, French Gothic Architecture of the 12th and 13th Centuries (Berkeley, 1983).
  • UNESCO World Heritage Centre, “Cologne Cathedral” and “Amiens Cathedral”.

Quick facts

Choir of Saint-Denis
1140-1144. Stone and glass. Saint-Denis, France
Notre-Dame de Paris
Begun 1163; flying buttresses from c. 1180. Limestone. Paris
Amiens Cathedral
Begun 1220; vault about 42 m. Stone. Amiens
Beauvais Cathedral choir
Begun 1225; vault about 48 m; partial collapse 1284. Stone. Beauvais
Cologne Cathedral
Begun 1248, completed 1880. Stone. Cologne
Salisbury Cathedral
1220-1258; spire about 123 m, 14th century. Stone. Salisbury
Milan Cathedral
Begun 1386. Marble. Milan
King's College Chapel
Fan vault 1508-1515. Stone. Cambridge