1401: a competition for a door
A good place to start is a contest. In 1401 the wool merchants’ guild of Florence invited artists to compete for a new pair of bronze doors for the Baptistery, each submitting a panel of the Sacrifice of Isaac. The two finalists were Lorenzo Ghiberti and Filippo Brunelleschi. Ghiberti won; Brunelleschi, so the story goes, turned to architecture. Both panels survive in the Bargello museum, and side by side they show the new ambition: classical bodies, real emotion and a story told with energy.

The contest also shows who paid. Early Renaissance art was commissioned art: guilds decorated their churches and niches, confraternities their chapels, rich families their palaces and burial chapels. A patron chose the subject, the materials and often the price of the blue, and the artist worked in a shop with assistants. The bigger picture of the period, from Florence to Rome and Venice, is in the hub on Italian Renaissance art.
Perspective: a window onto space
Around 1415-1420, according to his biographer Antonio Manetti, Brunelleschi stood in the door of Florence Cathedral and painted the Baptistery opposite on a small panel, with a hole in it. A viewer looked through the hole from the back, at a mirror held in front: the painting and the real building matched. Whatever the exact details, the point was proved. A picture could be built with geometry, with all parallel lines receding to a single vanishing point.
In 1435 the humanist and architect Leon Battista Alberti wrote the rules down in his treatise On Painting (De pictura), with an Italian version dedicated to Brunelleschi. He described the picture as an “open window” through which the story is seen. Brunelleschi meanwhile was building the dome of Florence Cathedral and churches based on simple proportions.
Masaccio: figures with weight
The first painter to use the new space fully was Masaccio, who died at about 26. In the Brancacci Chapel in Santa Maria del Carmine, painted with the older Masolino from about 1424 to 1428, his figures cast shadows from a single light, stand firmly on the ground and gather in real space, as in the scene of the Tribute Money. His Adam and Eve, driven out of Eden, show raw grief.

Donatello and Ghiberti: bronze and marble come alive
Sculpture led the way as much as painting. Donatello carved a Saint George for the armourers’ guild niche at Orsanmichele (about 1415-1417), alert and ready to move, and later cast the bronze David and the equestrian monument to the mercenary captain Gattamelata in Padua (1447-1453), the first large bronze horse and rider since antiquity.

Ghiberti, the winner of 1401, spent the rest of his life on doors. His second pair for the Baptistery (1425-1452), gilded and set with ten square Bible scenes in deep perspective, was later nicknamed the Gates of Paradise.

Workshops, convents and courts
The new art spread through workshops and through other kinds of patrons. In the convent of San Marco, the Dominican friar Fra Angelico painted each cell with a quiet fresco for prayer in the 1440s. Paolo Uccello painted the Battle of San Romano for a Florentine family in three panels (about 1435-1440), now split between Florence, Paris and London, a showpiece of foreshortened lances and horses.


Outside Florence, princely courts took up the new style. In Urbino, Duke Federico da Montefeltro employed Piero della Francesca, a painter and mathematician. In Mantua, Andrea Mantegna painted the Camera degli Sposi (1465-1474) for the Gonzaga family, with a ceiling that opens onto a painted sky full of figures looking down.

The end of the century: Botticelli and a crisis
In the last decades of the century, Florence under Lorenzo de’ Medici produced a more refined and poetic art. Sandro Botticelli painted mythologies such as the Primavera (about 1480), full of graceful figures in a flowering orchard. Then the mood darkened. After Lorenzo’s death in 1492 and the French invasion of 1494, the preacher Girolamo Savonarola dominated the city, and in 1497 Florentines burned luxury objects, books and pictures in the “bonfire of the vanities”.

By then a new generation, Leonardo, Michelangelo and Raphael, was ready to take the experiments of the Quattrocento further, in the phase known as the High Renaissance.
Where to see it
Florence has nearly everything: the Brancacci Chapel, the Bargello for sculpture, the Museo dell’Opera del Duomo for the original Gates of Paradise, San Marco for Fra Angelico and the Uffizi for paintings. Mantua has the Camera degli Sposi, and Padua Donatello’s Gattamelata.
Sources
- L. B. Alberti, On Painting (De pictura, 1435; Italian version 1436).
- A. Manetti, Vita di Filippo Brunelleschi (1480s).
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, “Florence in the Early Renaissance”.
- M. Baxandall, Painting and Experience in Fifteenth-Century Italy (Oxford, 1972).
- Museo Nazionale del Bargello and Gallerie degli Uffizi, collection records.



