Pre-Columbian Art

Who Left Teotihuacan Before the Aztecs Found It Empty?

Aztec visitors named the ruins Teotihuacan, 'place of the gods', long after it fell. Who were the people who left?

Teotihuacan, Avenue of the Dead seen from the Pyramid of the Moon, with the Pyramid of the Sun on the left, c. 100-550 C
Teotihuacan, Avenue of the Dead seen from the Pyramid of the Moon, with the Pyramid of the Sun on the left, c. 100-550 CE. Stone, rubble and stucco. Teotihuacan, State of Mexico. The ceremonial heart of a city of perhaps 100,000 people.Photo: Arian Zwegers from Brussels, Belgium, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The short answer

The people who left Teotihuacan were its own citizens. Around 550 CE the temples and palaces of its centre were burned, most likely in a revolt against the ruling elite, and over the following decades the great city emptied. When the Aztecs reached it, about eight centuries later, they found ruins and gave them a name.

A city of the gods, named by strangers

“Teotihuacan” is an Aztec word, in the Nahuatl language, usually translated as “the place of the gods” or “where the gods were born”. The Aztecs believed that the sun and moon of the present age had been created there, and they named its pyramids after them. What the city’s own people called it, and what language they spoke, we don’t know: Teotihuacan had images and signs, but no writing that has been read.

The story of the city itself is told in the guide to Teotihuacan and its pyramids. In short: from about 100 BCE it grew in the valley north-east of today’s Mexico City, and between about 100 and 550 CE it was the largest city in the Americas, with perhaps 100,000 inhabitants or more (some estimates reach 125,000), laid out on a grid around a single great avenue.

Plan of Teotihuacan, with the Avenue of the Dead, the Pyramids of the Sun and Moon, the Ciudadela and the residential co
Plan of Teotihuacan, with the Avenue of the Dead, the Pyramids of the Sun and Moon, the Ciudadela and the residential compounds. Drawing. The grid of the city follows one orientation, about 15 degrees east of north.Photo: WikiHistoriadoras, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Who lived there? A city of many peoples

Teotihuacan drew people from far away. Archaeologists have found whole neighbourhoods of foreigners: a quarter of families from Oaxaca, who kept their own way of burying the dead, and areas with pottery from the Gulf Coast and from the Maya region. Most people lived in large walled apartment compounds, each housing dozens of related families, with painted walls and their own shrines.

Teotihuacan, Tepantitla compound, mural with figures, plants and water, c. 450-650 CE
Teotihuacan, Tepantitla compound, mural with figures, plants and water, c. 450-650 CE. Fresco. Teotihuacan. Painted walls were part of daily life in the residential compounds, not only in the temples.Photo: Teseum (Flickr), CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The great temples, such as the Temple of the Feathered Serpent in the walled square called the Ciudadela, show a city with a strong religious and political centre. Who governed it is debated: there are no portraits of individual rulers, which has led some archaeologists to think that power was shared among a council of elite families rather than held by a single king.

Teotihuacan, Temple of the Feathered Serpent, Ciudadela, c. 200 CE
Teotihuacan, Temple of the Feathered Serpent, Ciudadela, c. 200 CE. Stone with traces of paint. Teotihuacan. The serpent heads that project from the facade were once painted and set with obsidian eyes.Photo: jschmeling, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The fire of around 550 CE

The clearest clue is a fire. Excavations along the Avenue of the Dead found that the temples and the palaces of the elite were burned, their statues broken and in some cases dragged away. The date is usually given as around 550 CE, although some studies place it later, between about 570 and 650. What matters is the pattern: the destruction is concentrated on the buildings of the rulers and the gods, not on the ordinary houses.

Teotihuacan, Palace of Quetzalpapalotl, carved pillars of the courtyard, c. 450-650 CE, partly reconstructed
Teotihuacan, Palace of Quetzalpapalotl, carved pillars of the courtyard, c. 450-650 CE, partly reconstructed. Stone with painted stucco. Teotihuacan. One of the elite buildings along the Avenue of the Dead.Photo: Peachseltzer, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

That pattern is the main reason why most archaeologists today reject the old idea of an invasion from outside. An enemy army would have had little reason to spare the houses of the city’s people and target only its sacred and political centre. In a study published in 2015 in the journal PNAS, the archaeologist Linda Manzanilla argued that the conflict was internal: the elites of the neighbourhoods, who controlled crafts and trade and were growing rich and independent, turned against the ruling elite of the centre.

Fire, revolt and drought: what else is argued

A revolt explains the fire, but perhaps not why it happened then. Other researchers point to slower troubles that came before: signs of food shortages and poor health in skeletons from the city’s last phase, a population that may already have been shrinking, and changes in climate in central Mexico in the sixth century that could have made the harvests less reliable. None of these causes excludes the others. A city under strain, with a rich and restless middle layer, may have been ready to break.

So the honest answer is layered. The fire is documented, its targets are clear, the internal revolt is the most widely held explanation, and the deeper causes are still being studied. Anyone who tells you that the fall of Teotihuacan is solved is simplifying.

Was it really empty when the Aztecs came?

Not completely. After the fire, the great city lost most of its people, but smaller communities went on living in the valley and even among the ruins, with a new style of pottery. What disappeared was the city as a centre of power. By the time the Aztecs founded Tenochtitlan in the fourteenth century, the pyramids of Teotihuacan were ancient, overgrown monuments, and that is how they entered Aztec myth.

The Aztecs treated the place with reverence. They made pilgrimages there, and when archaeologists excavated the Templo Mayor, the Aztecs’ great temple in Tenochtitlan, they found objects from Teotihuacan, including stone masks, buried among its offerings: antiques from a sacred past, about a thousand years old by then.

Teotihuacan, face panel, Classic period, 200-750 CE
Teotihuacan, face panel, Classic period, 200-750 CE. Greenstone. Dallas, Dallas Museum of Art. The calm, even features typical of Teotihuacan masks, a type later prized by the Aztecs.Photo: Daderot, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

So who left Teotihuacan? Its own inhabitants, in a slow departure that followed a violent turning point around 550 CE. The Aztecs found the empty monuments, named them after their gods and made the city part of their own story. Its place among the other early civilisations, in the Americas and beyond, is sketched in the beginner’s map of art history.

Where to see it

Teotihuacan is about 50 km north-east of Mexico City and is a UNESCO World Heritage Site since 1987. You can walk the Avenue of the Dead, see the Ciudadela and the Temple of the Feathered Serpent, and visit the site museums; climbing rules for the pyramids change, so check the official INAH site before you go. Many objects from the city are in the Teotihuacan hall of the Museo Nacional de Antropología in Mexico City.

Teotihuacan, Pyramid of the Sun, c. 200 CE
Teotihuacan, Pyramid of the Sun, c. 200 CE. Rubble core faced with stone. Teotihuacan. The largest building of the city, named by the Aztecs centuries after it was abandoned.Photo: Daniel Case, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Sources

  • L. R. Manzanilla, “Cooperation and tensions in multiethnic corporate societies using Teotihuacan, Central Mexico, as a case study”, PNAS 112 (2015).
  • R. Millon, “The Last Years of Teotihuacan Dominance”, in N. Yoffee and G. Cowgill (eds), The Collapse of Ancient States and Civilizations (Tucson, 1988).
  • G. L. Cowgill, Ancient Teotihuacan: Early Urbanism in Central Mexico (Cambridge, 2015).
  • L. López Luján, The Offerings of the Templo Mayor of Tenochtitlan (Albuquerque, 2005).
  • UNESCO World Heritage Centre, “Pre-Hispanic City of Teotihuacan”.

Quick facts

Place
Teotihuacan, State of Mexico, about 50 km north-east of Mexico City
Monument
Teotihuacan, city with the Avenue of the Dead, the Pyramids of the Sun and Moon and the Ciudadela
Date
c. 100 BCE-550 CE; centre burned c. 550 CE (later dates also proposed)
Material
Rubble and earth cores faced with stone and painted stucco
Status today
Archaeological zone; UNESCO World Heritage Site (1987)