Pre-Columbian Art

A Stalagmite Recorded a Maya Drought. Did It End the Cities?

Drought, war and strained farmland have all been blamed for the Maya collapse, and a stalagmite in Belize records the dry years.

Tikal, the temples of the Great Plaza rising above the rainforest
Tikal, the temples of the Great Plaza rising above the rainforest. Limestone. Tikal National Park, Guatemala. When the forest grew back over the city after the ninth century, it hid one of the largest Maya capitals.Photo: USAID Biodiversity & Forestry, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
The short answer

Partly, it seems. Between about 800 and 950 CE the great cities of the southern Maya lowlands were abandoned, and a stalagmite in Belize, with lake mud in Mexico, shows severe droughts in the same years. But drought struck societies already weakened by war and strained farmland, and the Maya people themselves never disappeared.

What collapsed, and what did not

In the eighth century the southern lowlands of Guatemala, Belize and southern Mexico held dozens of Maya royal cities, from Tikal to Palenque and Copán. Within about a century and a half, almost all of them stopped building. Kings stopped erecting dated monuments, palaces were left empty and the forest closed over the plazas. The last monument with a date in the Long Count, the Maya calendar of the kings, was carved at Toniná in Chiapas in 909.

Quiriguá, Stela D, 766, photograph of about 1900
Quiriguá, Stela D, 766, photograph of about 1900. Carved sandstone. Quiriguá, Guatemala. The columns of glyphs count the days from the start of the Maya era; after 909 no king set up a new dated monument.Photo: Alfred Percival Maudslay, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

That is the Classic Maya collapse: the end of a political system, the rule of divine kings, and of the cities that served it. The Maya themselves carried on. In northern Yucatán, cities such as Chichen Itza and Uxmal flourished after the south emptied, Maya kingdoms were still there when the Spanish arrived, and about six million people speak Maya languages today.

A climate record written in stone

Stalagmites grow drip by drip on cave floors, and each layer locks in a chemical trace of the rain that fell outside. In 2012 a team led by Douglas Kennett published a record taken from a stalagmite in Yok Balum Cave, in southern Belize, covering some 2,000 years. It showed a wet period around 440-660 CE, when the cities grew fastest, followed by a long drying trend and severe droughts in the ninth and tenth centuries.

Cross-section of a stalagmite, Diamond Caverns, Kentucky
Cross-section of a stalagmite, Diamond Caverns, Kentucky. Calcite. The growth layers record changes over time; the stalagmite from Yok Balum Cave in Belize was read in the same way in 2012.Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The stalagmite was not alone. Back in 1995, David Hodell and colleagues had found drought layers in the mud of Lake Chichancanab in Yucatán. In 2003 Gerald Haug’s team read the same dry years in the sediments of the Cariaco Basin off Venezuela. And in 2018 Nicholas Evans and colleagues measured water trapped in gypsum crystals from Lake Chichancanab and calculated that annual rainfall fell by 41-54% during the collapse, and by up to 70% in the worst years.

So was it the drought?

Most researchers now agree that the droughts were real and severe. Whether they caused the collapse is still debated. Maya cities depended on rain-fed maize and on reservoirs that filled in the wet season; a run of failed harvests would have hit them hard. But the timing is untidy. Some cities were in trouble before the worst droughts, and some northern cities, in an even drier landscape, did well in the same decades.

The Kennett team proposed a chain of causes. Rich rainfall had allowed populations to boom; when the climate turned, competition for food and land grew, and so did warfare. In the Petexbatún region of Guatemala, cities such as Dos Pilas threw up defensive walls in the late eighth century, some built from stones taken from their own temples and palaces. Kings whose power rested on their bond with the gods, and on their promise of rain, lost authority when the rain failed.

Dos Pilas, the ruins today
Dos Pilas, the ruins today. Limestone. Petén, Guatemala. In the late 8th century its people raised defensive walls across the royal plaza.Photo: Simon Burchell, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Other factors weighed too: forests cleared for fields and for the lime used in plaster, soil eroded from hillsides, trade routes shifting from inland rivers to the coasts. Many researchers now describe drought as the push that broke a system already under strain.

Why the north kept going

The puzzle that keeps the debate open is the north. Uxmal and the Puuc cities built some of their finest palaces in the ninth and tenth centuries, and Chichen Itza grew into the main power of Yucatán, with a new style that mixed Maya and central Mexican forms. Their people relied on natural sinkholes, the cenotes, and on trade along the coast. Societies under the same sky made different choices and met different fates.

Uxmal, Palace of the Governor, 10th century
Uxmal, Palace of the Governor, 10th century. Limestone with carved mosaic facade. Yucatán, Mexico. One of the great northern buildings raised after the southern cities had emptied.Photo: The Cosmonaut, CC BY-SA 2.5 ca, via Wikimedia Commons

The same pattern of a city that fell and was named later by others is told for Teotihuacan, in central Mexico, centuries earlier.

Sources

  • D. Kennett et al., “Development and Disintegration of Maya Political Systems in Response to Climate Change”, Science 338 (2012).
  • N. Evans et al., “Quantification of Drought during the Collapse of the Classic Maya Civilization”, Science 361 (2018).
  • D. Hodell, J. Curtis and M. Brenner, “Possible Role of Climate in the Collapse of Classic Maya Civilization”, Nature 375 (1995).
  • G. Haug et al., “Climate and the Collapse of Maya Civilization”, Science 299 (2003).
  • M. Medina-Elizalde and E. Rohling, “Collapse of Classic Maya Civilization Related to Modest Reduction in Precipitation”, Science 335 (2012).
  • A. Demarest, Ancient Maya: The Rise and Fall of a Rainforest Civilization (Cambridge, 2004).

Quick facts

Collapse of the southern cities
About 800-950 CE. Southern Maya lowlands: Guatemala, Belize, southern Mexico
Last Long Count date
909 CE. Carved monument. Toniná, Chiapas, Mexico
Yok Balum stalagmite
Kennett and colleagues, Science, 2012. Rainfall record of about 2,000 years. Southern Belize
Lake Chichancanab sediments
Hodell and colleagues, Nature, 1995; Evans and colleagues, Science, 2018 (rainfall down 41-54%). Quintana Roo, Mexico
Cariaco Basin sediments
Haug and colleagues, Science, 2003. Off the coast of Venezuela